Feedlot vs. grassfed cattle
Kim Wiley of Larga Vista Ranch & Dairy (www.largavistaranch.com) recently read my blog and had this to say about “Give Peas a Chance”. There is much wisdom in her words:
Unfortunately, the UN data on meat eating is based on stats from confined animal feeding operations (CAFOs) aka feedlots and confinement barns. Have you ever seen photos on PETA’s site of confinement hog and chicken operations? They are abhorrent!!!! There is a whole other world of grass-based animal husbandry that is actually good for the environment. Have you read “The Omnivore’s Dilemma” by Michael Pollan? It is an excellent eye-opening account of food production in this country and the difference between CAFO meat and grass-fed/finished meat. Pollan profiles farmer-advocate Joel Salatin (Google Polyface Farm) who explains just how amazing grass-based farming is in terms of large amount of food raised on a small amount of land (careful rotational grazing of many species,) how it builds soil, and is the best carbon sink there is! Also, Allan Savory and Holistic Management International are recovering thousands and thousands of acres (improving vegetative cover/carbon sink and effective rainfall) in dessicated areas of Africa with CATTLE properly grazed in a rotational pattern. They have great photos on this site.
Soy is now being grown on slashed and burned land in the Amazon. National Geographic put out an article on this about two years ago. Additionally, if non-organic soy is being consumed, it is most likely genetically modified soy grown in huge monoculture. This is not good for the land for many reasons. Furthermore, soy is packed full of anti-digestive nutrients (phytates) that block mineral absorption in the colon (see www.westonaprice.org). Fermented soy (tempeh, miso, natto) does not pose this problem.
As a grass farmer, I become frustrated that there isn’t often a differentiation made between feedlot meat animals and meat animals that come from a farm like ours that eat grass their entire lives. The UN stats are so prevalent in the dialogue of the green movement. I feel as though we who know about the vast difference between the feedlot and the grass farm, should try to do what we can to further understanding of a different way with other people who care about the environment. There are more choices than being a vegetarian and downing all of that soy or consuming CAFO meat. That subtle difference is what, I think, is the cutting edge of the conservation/environmental movement.
I do obtain my family’s meat from a farmer – Angela Wisnoski – who raises grassfed cows and pasture-raised pigs. As well, her eggs are from truly free-range hens (I recall one memorable day when she couldn’t deliver me any eggs because her hens had all flown the coop, so to speak, and were nesting in nearby trees). Animals that are raised on their natural feed are also more nutrient rich for us and more easily digested by us. However, for many people just getting their feet wet in the “green” waters, the distinctions can be confusing. However, it’s worth noting that there are alternatives to becoming a vegetarian for those carnivores loath to give up their burgers…even one day a week.